People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Awesome softshell crab and grouper sandwich. Best coleslaw I've had in a long time! The softshell season was just beginning so they only had huge crabs, bigger than what they normally put on the sandwiches. ”
“ Wow. We are staying in a home on Deal Island for vacation & so happy previous Google reviewers steered us toward this place (thank you!). We all got different combos and sides and there wasn’t anything we didn’t thoroughly enjoy! Kicking myself for turning down the rice pudding for dessert! (Though not sure we’d have room.. but might go back for lunch and rice pudding tomorrow!) Easy call-to-order, seamless pickup with very pleasant gentleman and woman at the windows, & 10/10 food.. & plenty of it! Pic attached of my combo #1 with sides of hush puppies & beets! Will include on our VRBO review as well! Wouldn’t want anyone to miss this place! Edited to update: went back for lunch and got the rice pudding (with the cinnamon). Let’s just say we won’t skip it next time! So good. ”
“ Everyone is so polite! The soft crabs are THE BEST I've ever had! Grouper sandwich is TOP NOTCH! Homemade tartar sauce is DELICIOUS! Check them out! You won't be disappointed ”
“ My boyfriend has been hyping this place up to me for years and today I finally made it! The crabcakes are so delicious, filled with flaky crab and very little to no filler/breading. Hush puppies tasted amazing with the homemade tartar sauce. Not a huge fan of potato salad, but this was some of the best I've ever eaten. It was all light and tasty. Inside dining is closed but it was the perfect day to sit and eat at the picnic table and enjoy the weather ”
“ The food is excellent. The prices are very reasonable. The people are friendly. Takeout only, which is fine. My only complaint is that they aren't open daily. They are better and cheaper than their competitors. You really can't go wrong. ”
“ This place has personality!!! I stopped here while on business in the Princess Anne area and I absolutely loved the food. They take your order in an odd way, but the New Yorker in me did not mind. I had the fried flounder with bay fries and a side salad. The fries was a 10...... I'm still dreaming about them. Flounder was good. This is now on my places to go when I'm down in this area. ”
“ This has the best food yet the greatest the best fish ever if you hate this place, I will come to your house, so leave a good review. Swear do this to me do not do not leave a bad review or I will you know you know ”
“ We came to visit from the UK and we were not disappointed. The soft crab sandwich was to die for, we had a seafood platter too which was incredible. What's more the owner is lovely, the vibe is amazing and the cinnamon rice pudding.... Wow! Sure, the service system is quirky, but to us, that's part of the charm of this place. The food speaks for its self. ”
Menu
Maryland Crab
Fried Oysters
US$12.95Bay Fries
Fries
Grilled Tuna Steak
US$7.95
About
Beach to Bay Seafood Company
Welcome to the delightful world of Beach to Bay Seafood Company, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Princess Anne, Maryland. Located at 12138 Carole Ln, this seafood haven promises a feast for the senses, serving up the freshest catches from the Atlantic and a medley of flavors that will transport you straight to the coast.
At Beach to Bay Seafood Company, the menu is a celebration of local seafood traditions, featuring hearty homemade soups such as the renowned Maryland Crab Soup, brimming with fresh vegetables and succulent crabmeat. For those who crave creamy indulgence, their Cream of Crab soup is a must-try, packed with generous portions of crab that leave a memorable impression.
Signature offerings like the New England Style Clam Chowder and Homemade Crab Dip (with a 24-hour notice required) showcase the company’s commitment to quality and authenticity. As the reviews enthusiastically highlight, you won't want to miss the opportunity to indulge in their crabcakes, which are celebrated for their rich flavor and minimal filler, allowing the star ingredient to shine.
- Sandwiches: The flounder, tilapia, and grouper sandwiches give you the best of what the ocean has to offer, each served at reasonable prices, with hits like the Fried Oysters providing a crunchy, salty perfection.
- Sides: Don’t forget to complement your meal with their signature Hush Puppies and Bay Fries, which add to the quintessential seaside experience.
The ambiance at Beach to Bay is laid-back and welcoming, perfect for enjoying your meal at one of their picnic tables or during a quick take-out service. Yet, it’s the warm hospitality that really makes it stand out—customers rave about the friendly staff and efficient service, emphasizing their role in making each visit a pleasure.
Business hours may sometimes limit access, which might be a small drawback for the devoted fans of this little seafood oasis, but the freshness and quality of the food—coupled with enthusiastic testimonials—will often keep you longing for more. As one customer put it perfectly, “You really can't go wrong.” Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure Beach to Bay Seafood Company is on your itinerary. Dive into their culinary delights—it’s an experience you won’t soon forget.
Book a table